CauseHealth goes to Evidence Live


Evidence Live is an annual conference, jointly hosted by the Centre for Evidence-Based Medicine, University of Oxford and The BMJ. This year, CauseHealth was represented in two of the sessions, by Elena Rocca and Rani Lill Anjum.

The first session was initiated by Philosophy of Pharmacology PI, Barbara Osimani, and was on Philosophy of Evidence: Dimensions of Evidence and Criteria for Standards Improvement. With her, she had the former and current directors of WHO’s Uppsala Monitoring Center for Drug Safety (UMC), Ralph Edwards and Marie Lindquist, Consultant Physician and Clinical Pharmacologist, Jeff Aronson, University of Oxford, and Elena and Rani from CauseHealth.

The ”reproducibility crisis” revealed the need for a deep reflection on current approaches to evidence evaluation and their reliability. Hidden moderators, publication bias and low power have been identified as possible sources for such results. Instead, some understand the failure of replication simply as a result of random error. Finally, others suggested to adopt a more comprehensive view to the analysis of evidence. Philosophy of Science and Epistemology can fruitfully complement Statistical knowledge, Epidemiology, and Medical Methodology in analyzing medical evidence from different perspectives. The roundtable intends to offer such an opportunity and to examine the interaction of different dimensions of evidence, such as consistency, reliability, variety with respect to methodology, context of enquiry, and theory.

In this session, Elena gave a brief presentation of how in pharmacovigilance, it is not enough to know that a drug is causally linked to the targeted effect: the treatment. In addition one needs to know which other dispositions the drug has, to produce side-effects, for instance. A problem with such side-effects, however, is that they are often rare and difficult to discover in clinical studies. Instead, she argued, that much can be learned about the causal dispositions of a drug from studying cases of causal failure in individual patients.

The second session was organised by Marie Lindquist and Jeffrey Aronson, on the evidence hierarchy. Together with Ralph, Elena, Rani and Bruce Hugman from UMC, they led the audience through three open space discussions:

Topic 1: What are the benefits and harms of deconstructing, even upending, the evidence hierarchy pyramid? Facilitator: Rani, Reporter: Marie

Topic 2: How can the stranglehold of the old paradigm, particularly the dominance of population risk statistics, be loosened to provide more sensitive and particular evidence that is of use to clinicians and patients? Facilitator: Elena, Reporter: Jeffrey

Topic 3: What specific measures can be taken to make wise and timely healthcare decisions for unique individuals when there are uncertainties arising from incomplete or conflicting data? Facilitator: Ralph, Reporter: Bruce


Author: CauseHealth

CauseHealth - Causation, Complexity and Evidence in Health Sciences

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: